Wes' Organ
Biggles
I checked today, Bardills Island is 8.2 miles to The City Ground for those of us who can't fly.
-
All - as you will understand, the forum is exceptionally busy at this time. The admins and moderators simply don't have time to read every post in every thread. Could you PLEASE use the "Report" option below a post to flag any content that you feel we need to be aware of. We'll review everything reported as a priority and deal with it accordingly. Thank you.
The World Famous City Ground - Home of the PROPER WORLD‘S OLDEST LEAGUE CLUB
- Thread starter donny
- Start date
Professor Wolfgang Schnell BSc. PhD.
Fulchester United
Not Elvis Costello's finest work...
I'm Red Till Dead
Stuart Pearce
Yesterday's Daily Mail interview says he's now worth £3 billion. Moves him up a couple of places if true.
Robertson
Geoff Thomas
Doubtful that 777 is worth £8 billion
Wes' Organ
Biggles
They're moving less than a mile and still in Everton.
We're looking at 8.2 miles unless you have wings and barely in Notts let alone Nottingham.
chaospunx
Geoff Thomas
No thanks sounds wank
'mist rollin in'
First Team Squad
One of the reasons I want to keep the City Ground is purely because of nostalgia and being a football romantic. I know these aren't good enough reasons and I've accepted that a move to the right location is probably inevitable. It just feels that with every season, we lose a part of football that makes it beautiful...
VAR ruining goal celebrations, scrapping FA Cup replays, Financial rules, Closed shop Premier League and now this latest suggestion of domestic games being played abroad
I know it's nothing to do with the City Ground, but the direction of football in the future doesn't look great, so it's natural to want to hold on to the past. It's all part of the changing times and if building a new stadium helps us generate commercial opportunities and compete in the future, I can get behind it, I just can't back the Toton move.
VAR ruining goal celebrations, scrapping FA Cup replays, Financial rules, Closed shop Premier League and now this latest suggestion of domestic games being played abroad
I know it's nothing to do with the City Ground, but the direction of football in the future doesn't look great, so it's natural to want to hold on to the past. It's all part of the changing times and if building a new stadium helps us generate commercial opportunities and compete in the future, I can get behind it, I just can't back the Toton move.
Quntib Hollox
Jack Burkitt
There’s a very fine line!
I would add, I have nothing against Newark, it is a really cool place; I mean, I was born there so it must be.
Lady Penelope
First Team Squad
On the firms time, a couple of colleagues and myself have done a back of an envelope costing on Toton, the assumptions being:
multi-modal transport solutions
capacity of stadium circa 47000
road access via A52 Bardills with enhancements at the m1 / A52 intersection
tram terminus to remain where it is but with passing loops to allow faster trams to beeston and the city, longer platforms at some stops so two trams can be couple together
rail connection (electrified) from Toton to Nottingham Midland via Long Eaton (costs and location of a new station there not included) ... could be tram / train technology like the Sheffield to Rotherham, erm, pilot scheme (trams but they run on heavy rail lines).
Sit back folks, we've got this at just over £520 million at todays prices.
Of course, like all such projects in this country, it need not cost this, but it will.
Planning would be at least five years to conclusion if we started tomorrow then add two or three years to build.
It's not happening. it's definitely not happening.
Even if our skilled and experienced but admittedly back of an envelope (well, it was done on a Mac but hey) costings are 30% over or under (more probably the latter)... there's your answer. We have not worked from detailed drawings because there are none, we have simply applied our collective experience and the costs are huge.
The biggest obstacles: road changes on the A52 and at Bardills
The train link (the project would not work without it)
The fact that the local authorities directly involved (City, Broxtowe and the County), plus the tram company, the road and rail people and the other statutory consultees, then also Erewash (Earwash?) as a neighboroughing Council and impacted authority, Derbys too no doubt... nightmare.
multi-modal transport solutions
capacity of stadium circa 47000
road access via A52 Bardills with enhancements at the m1 / A52 intersection
tram terminus to remain where it is but with passing loops to allow faster trams to beeston and the city, longer platforms at some stops so two trams can be couple together
rail connection (electrified) from Toton to Nottingham Midland via Long Eaton (costs and location of a new station there not included) ... could be tram / train technology like the Sheffield to Rotherham, erm, pilot scheme (trams but they run on heavy rail lines).
Sit back folks, we've got this at just over £520 million at todays prices.
Of course, like all such projects in this country, it need not cost this, but it will.
Planning would be at least five years to conclusion if we started tomorrow then add two or three years to build.
It's not happening. it's definitely not happening.
Even if our skilled and experienced but admittedly back of an envelope (well, it was done on a Mac but hey) costings are 30% over or under (more probably the latter)... there's your answer. We have not worked from detailed drawings because there are none, we have simply applied our collective experience and the costs are huge.
The biggest obstacles: road changes on the A52 and at Bardills
The train link (the project would not work without it)
The fact that the local authorities directly involved (City, Broxtowe and the County), plus the tram company, the road and rail people and the other statutory consultees, then also Erewash (Earwash?) as a neighboroughing Council and impacted authority, Derbys too no doubt... nightmare.
Mr. Blonde
John Robertson
"Broooooooownhills Ground!
Oh exhaust fumes rolling in from the UK's largest motorhome dealership!"
Gariballdidaz
Youth Team
While I was at work today listening to a very informative presentation regarding mental health week I may have let my mind wander a bit and decided to look at the proposal of rotating the City Ground thru 90 degrees. The good news is, we can have a 47.5k stadium with minimal disruption, the bad news is I didn't really take much of the presentation on board... and the Trent End may now be in the Trent.
Come on Cartledge get your finger out.... I really don't know what all the fuss is about - turns out you just need Google maps, the snip tool and a bit of a vivid imagination
Come on Cartledge get your finger out.... I really don't know what all the fuss is about - turns out you just need Google maps, the snip tool and a bit of a vivid imagination
Last edited:
football post
I'm still here Crewton
I've been waiting for over 20 years for the buzz the matchday experience gives us now. Drinking in the packed quirky pubs around the station The anticipation as we're walking down Arkwright Street through the Meadows. Then the shuffling over Trent Bridge as the excitement level goes up another notch.
What we have now is special, really special. As a youngster in the 80's we had some wonderful times but nothing compares to how it's been over the last couple of seasons.
Home Saturdays are brilliant now - and this is with a poor team.
We must find a way to make the necessary improvements at the City Ground.
What we have now is special, really special. As a youngster in the 80's we had some wonderful times but nothing compares to how it's been over the last couple of seasons.
Home Saturdays are brilliant now - and this is with a poor team.
We must find a way to make the necessary improvements at the City Ground.
valspoodle
Steve Chettle
The US has the benefit of being so bloody big and having lots of space. And they are happy to drive many miles to get anywhere. So if they want a new ground they build it miles away, surround it with acres of car parks and the customers seem happy to accept the change. Some of the car parks are so big it's almost like walking from WB to Toton!
We talk of moving less than ten miles and the heavens fall in. The Yanks make do without a Greggs or chippie being handy by taking a complete BBQ set in the back of the pick up truck.
We talk of moving less than ten miles and the heavens fall in. The Yanks make do without a Greggs or chippie being handy by taking a complete BBQ set in the back of the pick up truck.
'mist rollin in'
First Team Squad
One question that's been on my mind with the stadium debate is this...
Do we have 50,000 fans?
We know there are approx 20,000 season ticket holders and 11,000 on the waiting list (although this figure will be over inflated as it covers members who automatically get signed up on the list).
We know that all home games sell out, so we sell 27,000 tickets for each home game. There's still around 15,000 to 20,000 fans to find to fill a large stadium. Given the price of Premier League tickets, would we actually fill it week in/week out; we're not a large city compared to London, Birmingham, Leeds or Manchester. Surrounding cities have obviously got their own clubs.
I know we've got fans across the world and there are lots of fans who watch and listen across the country, but would we actually fill a large stadium week in/week out, not just against the big clubs, but at home against Bournemouth, a Luton type club etc.
Considering that 5 years ago, attendance at a bang average Championship match would be 25,000, have we got double that amount of fans willing to pay and fill a large stadium?
Do we have 50,000 fans?
We know there are approx 20,000 season ticket holders and 11,000 on the waiting list (although this figure will be over inflated as it covers members who automatically get signed up on the list).
We know that all home games sell out, so we sell 27,000 tickets for each home game. There's still around 15,000 to 20,000 fans to find to fill a large stadium. Given the price of Premier League tickets, would we actually fill it week in/week out; we're not a large city compared to London, Birmingham, Leeds or Manchester. Surrounding cities have obviously got their own clubs.
I know we've got fans across the world and there are lots of fans who watch and listen across the country, but would we actually fill a large stadium week in/week out, not just against the big clubs, but at home against Bournemouth, a Luton type club etc.
Considering that 5 years ago, attendance at a bang average Championship match would be 25,000, have we got double that amount of fans willing to pay and fill a large stadium?
Lefkasman
Ian Bowyer
The last thing we need to do is get more like bloody Americans. They think the answer to everything is the car when actually it's too many cars causing the problems.
Sent from my 23124RA7EO using Tapatalk
If you look at Everton's move, however sad it is to leave Goodison, if i were a fan i'd be excited about a beautiful new stadium closer to the city centre in a unique waterfront setting. That ground will become iconic and add a real cache to the club. Why on earth would we decide to spend what you would assume to be a similar amount of money to do precisely the opposite (at Toton). The more i think about it the more confident i am that £500-£750 million is just something Marinarkis just won't spend. We'll still be at the city ground in exactly the same position in 5 years time waiting for the shipping container boxes to arrive..
Especially given the number of people who would give up going if we moved to Toton..
We've got about 15000 who will be there no matter what.
Another 8000 who will turn up when things are going well, 3000 away fans and another 4000 who are Premier League only fans.
Of course, in reality it means that the 4000 is doubled to 8000 at the cost of the 15000 die hards.
So that's 30000
Then the club tells us they have a waiting list of 11000, that's 41000.
Throw in a bit of success on the pitch and we could get another 10000 waiting to go on the waiting list.
It's going to look pretty empty when there are 15000 of us crammed in to watch a League 1 game against Rotherham.
Shearstone
Born again Christian
Marinakis
Shearstone
Born again Christian
The 11,000 signed up for a season ticket at The City Ground though, it won't be that number who take up a season ticket in Toton. It will be at most 10,999 cos I'm on the list and I'm not bloody going there
Listen 'ere young man
Jack Burkitt
You don't need to fill it week in week out, 7 to 8 matches of 45k plus against the cartel, can always offer more away tickets for these.
And 35k-ish for the 'smaller' clubs.
If you look at the average attendances vs the stadium capacities throughout the Premier league, the difference is around 2 to 3k at most so they all run at full capacity more or less.
Sent from my EVR-L29 using Tapatalk
And 35k-ish for the 'smaller' clubs.
If you look at the average attendances vs the stadium capacities throughout the Premier league, the difference is around 2 to 3k at most so they all run at full capacity more or less.
Sent from my EVR-L29 using Tapatalk