• All - as you will understand, the forum is exceptionally busy at this time. The admins and moderators simply don't have time to read every post in every thread. Could you PLEASE use the "Report" option below a post to flag any content that you feel we need to be aware of. We'll review everything reported as a priority and deal with it accordingly. Thank you.

Snatchday 1: Nottingham Forest Vs the PGMOL

Cloughie1975

John Robertson
I acknowledged I was cherry picking too


The point I was making is not that the EPL is competitive, but that the top division had been uncompetitive on the same terms before the EPL.

The 20 years prior to the EPL had already set the tone.
I’d argue that the tone was set in 1983 (9 years before the formation of the Premier League)
when home clubs were allowed to keep their own gate receipts (prior to that away clubs
kept a share-so a visit to say Old Trafford or Anfield could be lucrative).
The period from 1972 (20 years before the Premier League was formed) until 1983 was far
more competitive with Derby (twice),Forest and Villa all becoming champions and other
unfashionable clubs such as Stoke,QPR and Ipswich coming close.
 

Redemption

Agenda Benda
I’d argue that the tone was set in 1983 (9 years before the formation of the Premier League)
when home clubs were allowed to keep their own gate receipts
Even if this is correct, these changes aren't made in a vacuum... they have antecedents.

What caused the league to make these changes? How were the clubs involved? Etc (I'm not expect answers, btw im being pointedly rhetorical )

Football is evolutionary in the sport itself, in the business that operates it and co-evolutionary with the community it draws its fans from, and with the technological and economic practices of the society it is part of.
 

Cloughie1975

John Robertson
Even if this is correct, these changes aren't made in a vacuum... they have antecedents.

What caused the league to make these changes? How were the clubs involved? Etc (I'm not expect answers, btw im being pointedly rhetorical )

Football is evolutionary in the sport itself, in the business that operates it and co-evolutionary with the community it draws its fans from, and with the technological and economic practices of the society it is part of.
You didn‘t want any answers,R-but I’ll give you one (so to speak).
The top clubs threatened a breakaway so were allowed to keep their home gate receipts
in 1983 as an appeasement tactic to keep the league together.
The Premier League was still formed in 1992 despite this.
 

alabamared

Stuart Pearce
I've long been a reformist when it comes to football, but I'm also a realist.

The debate has to happen about whatvis that fans actually want and what does it mean in real terms.

I don't have any answers personally but I don't see people having too many answers either. I started a thread weeks ago about what changes people want but no really wants to offer anything.

And I suspect that's because we're so conditioned to retail offers we can consume.

And there is no mileage in 'the good old days.'
You're correct that we can't go backwards but which way is forward?
For me I think we need to get control of wages and transfer fees, quite how to do that wihout mandating caps is difficult and I wouldn't want teh job.
THe EPL is currently a product and not a sporting competition, I would like to see that change.
 

Robertson

Viv Anderson
You're correct that we can't go backwards but which way is forward?
For me I think we need to get control of wages and transfer fees, quite how to do that wihout mandating caps is difficult and I wouldn't want teh job.
THe EPL is currently a product and not a sporting competition, I would like to see that change.
Capping ‘commercial income’ against FFP at about £20m would be a start. The big six clubs are topping a billion a year between them in income claimed to offset expenses on wages and player purchases. No wonder there is wage inflation.
 

Robertson

Viv Anderson
Limit how much of the green bars can count against FFP basically.

If they really are making all that money what’s not to like for the big clubs? It’ll go into their pockets rather than having to spend it on player wages.

IMG_4560.jpeg
 

REDDERS78

Jack Armstrong
You know what I'd like to see if we get through all this circus, and manage to stay up this year? the Big man in Nottingham town centre with a microphone singing I did it my way with a silver glitter suit on that would be fucgging awesome

Sent from my CLT-L09 using Tapatalk
I would love to see that!

A lot of people on here wouldnt though, I cant imagine some wanting to see such a thing after spending so many hours critisizing the bloke on a football forum.
 
So firstly you are comparing 20 years with the 30 years I quoted (and then accuse me of cherry picking?)

So let us just do a little deeper comparison over two sets of thirty years.
Over the final thirty years of the First Division
13 different teams won the title
14 different teams were runners up
15 different teams finished 3rd
30 years of the EPL
7 different teams have won the title
7 different were runners up
10 different teams have finished third

If you accept that the 'elite' teams are Man C, Man U, Chelsea, Arsenal, Liverpool and Spurs then in the last ten years only one team (Leicester) outside of these elite have finished in the top 3. The same is true of the prior 10 years again only one team outside of the elite finished in the top 3 (Newcastle United).
So apart from those two occasions all instances of a non elite team finishing the top 3 were confined to the first ten years of the EPL.
So tell me that the EPL is competitive.
There are many leagues where it is the big 2 or even the big 1, but yes outside of the cartel 6 or so, your hands are tied.
 

Lefkasman

Ian Bowyer
But on the same basis there are many who will.

Every fan that gives up a season ticket because of cost will be replaced by one that can afford. There is no shortage of take up.
Oh I don't imagine there is any shortage. A bit like folk willing to pay a couple of hundred quid to see a band who are well past their selling by date at a venue with shit acoustics.

Sent from my 23124RA7EO using Tapatalk
 

Statto

Free Kick Specialist

Redemption

Agenda Benda
Oh I don't imagine there is any shortage. A bit like folk willing to pay a couple of hundred quid to see a band who are well past their selling by date at a venue with shit acoustics.

Sent from my 23124RA7EO using Tapatalk
Just scrolling on my twitter timeline and people who were properly vexed last week now announcing they've just renewed.

Captive audience. Etc.
 

chaospunx

Geoff Thomas
Ok was bored so knocked this up i have no doubt it will make f*** all differance but be interesting to see what kind of number of signatures it could attract i can still edit it so any improvements let me know as i have the mental and writing ability of your average 5 year old 🤣🤣

Share far and wide

 

Lefkasman

Ian Bowyer
Just scrolling on my twitter timeline and people who were properly vexed last week now announcing they've just renewed.

Captive audience. Etc.
I've not really got anything against people who want to renew and have a grumble, it's their money and their choice. I'd hate to think people were getting into debt for it though.

Sent from my 23124RA7EO using Tapatalk
 

BryanRoy22

Ian Bowyer
If VAR audio transparency became the norm and we got to hear the decisions as they were being made (or even shortly after), one thing I can definitely guarantee is that it would quickly become far more professional and, by extension, competent.

Because let's face it, the main reason they've not released any audio publicly from the Everton match is almost certainly on account of it being a dumpster fire of ineffectual twattery.
I have never understood why, from the outset, VAR was never a live audio to the players and audience like it is in rugby. Communicating transparently throughout.

In rugby, things are cleared up so openly to everyone and huge aggressive lads on the pitch often accept the decisions without any complaint.

It should be easy. It could be easy. But Sky Sports/Premier League enjoy the drama. That's clear to see from their adverts and build up of a League 1 game. "This is incredible. The drama. The excitement. MK Dons against Peterborough. Only an hour away in travel but could be so far apart this evening in the league table. This is why you keep coming back. Strap in for the ride of your life".

In some ways, what's happening with Forest right now is (ironically) probably what they want in terms of online clicks, which generates more attention and sales. Everything is playing into their hands right now.
 

YellowBelly Red

Viv Anderson
As someone that spends thousands every season following Forest, I'm now asking why I can't hear the VAR audio from last weeks game?

Exactly what have the PGMOL got to hide? Why nearly a week later, has this not been released? Why is Attwell still being allowed to officiate games? Why is Howard Webb still in a job?

Something isn't right, so as a fan/customer, show me and the other thousands, some respect and get the audio released. We live in a digital age, so it should be so simple.

Its obvious that the EPL and Sky didn't want Everton to go down. It suits Sky to have two Merseyside derbies, and relegation could well have meant administration for Everton.

I just feel like myself and all the other Forest plans are being taken for mugs here.
 

Strummer

Socialismo O Muerte!
LTLF Minion
How long did it take them to get liverpools audio out?
24 hours, but that was because some bloke in a tracksuit with a perm and a ‚tache chucked a bin through the window of PGMOL HQ and nicked it.
 
Top Bottom