tomasj
Geoff Thomas
I thought Forest were top six candidates, really.
I expected a difficult season given our European commitments,VP-but we haven’t helped ourselves one bit!At the end of last season, regardless of what happened then, I don't think any of us could imagine the implosion this season.
It was just so spectacular and sudden. Many even thought the recruitment was reasonable!
So far.I actually predicted 19th place so we've done better than I thought.
I had hopes for Jimmy Sinclair but he appears to have been removed from the first team orbit in recent months.I'd be more confident about a quick return, should we drop, if we had a few exciting youngsters who were good enough to make an impression. As far as I'm aware we only have Abbot who hasn't greatly impressed.
I put a bet on that too! This team is capable of that for sure, but a mental season has clearly taken a toll. Can’t be easy, regardless of the pay packet.I thought Forest were top six candidates, really.
Even with Wood back, without a genuine Elanga replacement this squad is currently not capable of a top 6 finish IMOI put a bet on that too! This team is capable of that for sure, but a mental season has clearly taken a toll. Can’t be easy, regardless of the pay packet.
I also put a bet on Chris Wood being top PL goalscorer.
When the fun stops. Stop.
Last season every player played the best they had ever done in their careers, and the squad also formed a great team.Even with Wood back, without a genuine Elanga replacement this squad is currently not capable of a top 6 finish IMO
There's a reason we finished 7th last year even with them here. We lack depth and goals from other areas.
Most of that is factual but I think that labelling Anderson as "inconsistent" is very harsh. Like MGW recently he has tried almost too hard and this leads to mistakes. Overall his level of performance rates amongst the very best that I have seen in a Reds shirt and I've seen them from Colin Addison onwards!Last season every player played the best they had ever done in their careers, and the squad also formed a great team.
Sels won the Golden Gloves, and was injury free.
Aina was the best RB in the Prem and was injury free.
Milenkovic and Murillo were impregnable.
Willian’s was the best LB in the Prem and injury free.
Anderson, Gibbs-White, Wood, Elanga, and Hudson-Odoi were on fire.
This season Sels has suffered injuries and been shaken.
Aina is still trying to get over a serious injury and is a shadow of last season’s class.
Milenkovic and Murillo look like strangers this season.
Williams has been Mr Consistent.
Sangare has finally come of age.
Anderson is inconsistent.
MGW has improved recently after last summer’s farce.
Wood has been out since netting twice in the opening game of the season.
Elanga has gone, and CHO blows cold, and occasionally mildly warm.
4 managers, recruitment run by headless chickens, and an owner blinded by his own ego.
No one need say more to account for our reversion to a struggling provincial make-weight.
All this talk of players checking out, looking to move in the summer and not trying is frankly ridiculous. What about the players for the other teams down there? According to folk on here they’re all busting a gut, getting results and sending us down. Again completely ridiculous- we’ve had some cracking performances this season just not enough to be safe, it’s still all to play for and both the players and the manager know this. Stop the booing and get behind the team, we are actually in quite a lot better position at this stage of the season than our first season back up and have far better players. Puts tin hat on and quickly retreats.It’s not something that comes to me easily, to accuse some players of checking out but I do think it is now happening. The fact we have so few alternatives to the regular starting XI does complicate the issue, as does the confusion created by having 4 managers, each with a different approach to playing styles and man-management.
Throw EM’s volatile interventions with players and managers and it is a right poisonous club to be at. Us fans seem to have been forgotten about as interested parties. The club seems to see us purely as economic units.
All this talk of players checking out, looking to move in the summer and not trying is frankly ridiculous. What about the players for the other teams down there? According to folk on here they’re all busting a gut, getting results and sending us down. Again completely ridiculous- we’ve had some cracking performances this season just not enough to be safe, it’s still all to play for and both the players and the manager know this. Stop the booing and get behind the team, we are actually in quite a lot better position at this stage of the season than our first season back up and have far better players. Puts tin hat on and quickly retreats.
Same here. Just with Europe being on the cards, my expectation was to finish between 15th and 12th at best because of that extra burden. Even if we'd have signed some great second-string players, they've still got a bed in. The team's still got to gel. It's still new to a lot of players. You've got to be realistic about it.Said bottom 7 all along.
Losing Elanga was huge as he was a massive goal threat and losing Wood for most of the season makes things 10 x worse from a scoring point of view. They haven't been replaced properly.
Last season was our pinnacle and mostly everything went for us. This season is the complete opposite.
I'll say is again - bad recruitment has cost us big time!
Edu - are you still in the building?
We are in an almost identical position to our first season back (27 points from 28 games in both campaignsAll this talk of players checking out, looking to move in the summer and not trying is frankly ridiculous. What about the players for the other teams down there? According to folk on here they’re all busting a gut, getting results and sending us down. Again completely ridiculous- we’ve had some cracking performances this season just not enough to be safe, it’s still all to play for and both the players and the manager know this. Stop the booing and get behind the team, we are actually in quite a lot better position at this stage of the season than our first season back up and have far better players. Puts tin hat on and quickly retreats.
We are in an almost identical position to our first season back (27 points from 28 games in both campaigns
and 1 point clear from relegation in 22/23 and 2 points this year).
I think what has caused disenchantment amongst many supporters is that they can see the obvious mistakes that
have been made which are likely to drag us down whereas in our first season back most of us were just enjoying
the ride regardless.
Also we were massive underdogs in the first season which got the crowd right behind us.First season back the manager and most of the squad were likeable too.
This season it's hard to back a manager who's only been here for 3 hours and will likely leave before the afternoon is done, and most of the players we've signed are also so half-arsed that it's impacted on the wider squad likability as well.
Yep mostly correct but like others I would question labelling Anderson as inconsistent is very harsh - he has been our best player in many games and in top 3 in most. Last season all the stars aligned and we had an incredible season with an absolute purple patch in the middle. It fizzled out towards the end and this season has continued in a similar vein. We also haven’t had Wood and even if we had it would have been an absolute miracle for him to repeat his conversion rate. We will all look back on last season as a very enjoyable one off, much like 1995, 1967 and 1959 before - the only time we have not been a provincial club trying to keep up with the big boys was the glory years under king Brian and for that we should all be grateful- well those of us over 50 anyway.Last season every player played the best they had ever done in their careers, and the squad also formed a great team.
Sels won the Golden Gloves, and was injury free.
Aina was the best RB in the Prem and was injury free.
Milenkovic and Murillo were impregnable.
Willian’s was the best LB in the Prem and injury free.
Anderson, Gibbs-White, Wood, Elanga, and Hudson-Odoi were on fire.
This season Sels has suffered injuries and been shaken.
Aina is still trying to get over a serious injury and is a shadow of last season’s class.
Milenkovic and Murillo look like strangers this season.
Williams has been Mr Consistent.
Sangare has finally come of age.
Anderson is inconsistent.
MGW has improved recently after last summer’s farce.
Wood has been out since netting twice in the opening game of the season.
Elanga has gone, and CHO blows cold, and occasionally mildly warm.
4 managers, recruitment run by headless chickens, and an owner blinded by his own ego.
No one need say more to account for our reversion to a struggling provincial make-weight.
Maybe I was harsh on Anderson, but I do think his performance levels have dropped off, as have most of the players levels.Most of that is factual but I think that labelling Anderson as "inconsistent" is very harsh. Like MGW recently he has tried almost too hard and this leads to mistakes. Overall his level of performance rates amongst the very best that I have seen in a Reds shirt and I've seen them from Colin Addison onwards!