Smith or Camp?

smithy

smithy

Geoff Thomas
Well we seem to have a load of shit being chucked around about our absolute rubbish young squad who finished 3rd in the league. But no one as yet seems to of mentioned that last nights performance from Lee Camp was possibly his worst for Forest.

Surely this begs the question, who is a better keeper, Smith or Camp!!??lol
 
B

Bridgfordred79

Guest
Paul Smith.

But Lee Camp has had a fantastic season.
 
Dadford

Dadford

Banned
Came through to collect high balls when needed, made some saves, distributed well.
Could be at "fault" but also had a save called magnificent.
3 defenders turned to stone after Camp made the save when DJ scored his 3rd.
Camp all the way. Even the experts say how much difference it makes to the defence when a keeper does all the good stuff Camp does.
Smith will never instill enough belief in a defence when it has to do half his job for him.
 
Baronvon

Baronvon

Jack Burkitt
Smith.

That said I don't think Camp had a particularly bad game (though from the Trent end I didn't have the best view of the goals that went in) - his save in the first half from Adam was fantastic.
 
C

cknu

Viv Anderson
Camp's distribution has got worse as the season has gone on but his saving ability is better than Smith's. After he gave away that goal he was furious, punched his post and then looked to th heavens!
 
FBS

FBS

Steve Chettle
Camp all the way

Whether you blame him for the first goal or not, you have to look at what could have happened if he had stayed in his goal - probably the same end result
 
R

red9

First Team Squad
You cannot even question Camps Ability The person who put this thread up is a KNOB! Camp for ENGLAND! Behind Hart and James
 
Flaggers

Flaggers

May not be the best moderator on LTLF, but he's...
LTLF Minion
:frantic:
 
incapable hulk

incapable hulk

Best served cold
Camp. He made some good saves last night, and his only real error was one poor goal kick which cost us.

Smiths awful.
 
4

420

First Team Squad
Every keeper in the world makes mistakes, theres no point in getting on Camps back. Camp overall has had an excellent season. I'm happy we have a keeper of Smith's quality on the bench though, especially when i think back only a few years ago when Barry Roache was making the starting 11 lol

ENGLAND'S NUMBER ONE! :yes:
 
Dadford

Dadford

Banned
Please don't make the Smithers beg the mods to delete the thread.
It mas made law not to talk ill of Smith last year.
 
adam09

adam09

Bob McKinlay
Apart from the one bad kick, what did Camp do wrong?

Blackpool's keeper made 5 bad kicks last night but we couldn't punish them because their defenders never ventured forward out of position.

Where our central midfield and Perch were when Camp kicked it straight to them I don't know, totally missing, but that's down to poor tactics and organisation.
 
Hoax

Hoax

Grenville Morris
I think we really need to bring Buffon into this argument to end it once and for all
 
R

red9

First Team Squad
Not knocking Smith, he is a top bloke, can keep also The idiot who started this thread is just that!
 
king_congo_red

king_congo_red

Ale Ape
Can't believe so many people who spend a lot of time posting here ALWAYs take this seriously.
 
Azza

Azza

Viv Anderson
I've always been a Smith fan, and still believe that he's a brilliant keeper - far better than a number two for a Championship side. But Camp has been absolutely outstanding this season.

Yeah he had a bad game yesterday. Yeah it was his fault for one of Blackpool's goals, but if you take away the amount of points he's saved us this season, then we would have been struggling outside the playoffs.
 
R

red9

First Team Squad
Azza said:
I've always been a Smith fan, and still believe that he's a brilliant keeper - far better than a number two for a Championship side. But Camp has been absolutely outstanding this season.

Yeah he had a bad game yesterday. Yeah it was his fault for one of Blackpool's goals, but if you take away the amount of points he's saved us this season, then we would have been struggling outside the playoffs.
Click to expand...

Someone with sense!! ONwards and upwards NOTTINGHAM FOREST!
 
C

clusternakker

Guest
Camp conceded 4 shockingly simple goals, shouldn't have come out for the chip, had an eternity to read the deflection. Inept. With Smith we'd have won 3-0 and be playing premiership football next season. Camp needs to be sacked.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom