Seargant Reddog
First Team Squad
Just flashed up that sky sources believe Newcastle Utd have made an undisclossed bid for James Perch....
:wacko:
wouldnt like to see him go to Newcastle
:wacko:
wouldnt like to see him go to Newcastle
Perch to Newcastle
- Thread starter Seargant Reddog
- Start date
puds1970
Steve Chettle
Could do the same job as agent Clough. :wink:
In all seriousness I wouldn't want Perch to leave unless we get decent cover in first.
In all seriousness I wouldn't want Perch to leave unless we get decent cover in first.
sawleyjeff
A. Trialist
Just seen this, can't really see it happening as Billy keeps re-iterating the squad needs adding to not reducing.
Also Perchy covers alot of positions so again unlikely we'll sell.
However everybody has there price.
Also Perchy covers alot of positions so again unlikely we'll sell.
However everybody has there price.
Jonathan
Resident foodie!
Think we'd be divvy to sell him to a rival side.
I imagine they're signing him as a right back because I think I head last night that Danny Simpson's loan isn't being renewed beyond this month.
I imagine they're signing him as a right back because I think I head last night that Danny Simpson's loan isn't being renewed beyond this month.
dbarraclough
Viv Anderson
Wouldn't want to see it, what with a recurring left back problem back on the horizon. Even if we secured Shorey for the season, I wouldn't be satisfied unless it was silly money (2.5 mill+)
puds1970
Steve Chettle
Couple that with the fact that they don't fancy Ryan Taylor as a right back I'm sure thats why their after Perchy.Jonathan said:
If we let him go then we must have something else lined up.
L
lard
Guest
I cant see us selling to the only team above us either.Jonathan said:
fsor12
First Team Squad
The lad deserves his chance let him go, Please please please cya Perch ;D
RedRobbo
Jack Armstrong
Keep him - his flexibility in covering a number of positions could be invaluable later in the season.
Unless of course Billy ( and the acquisitions committee ) have got players lined up.
Unless of course Billy ( and the acquisitions committee ) have got players lined up.
RedMark
Viv Anderson
I wondered how long it would take foe Calderwood to return for more. Remember he obviously highly rates him as he made Perch captain.
garrilla
Viv Anderson
it goes to show hoe Perch is viewed in the football world
Mist Rolling In...
First Team Squad
Absolutely no chance (in my opinion)... Billy loves Perchinho, as he has said numerous times over the last few months!
thehockleyhustler
Stuart Pearce
No way should we strengthen Newcastle's squad right now even if he can't get into our side
It's in their local rag too....
http://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/nufc...nited-in-bid-for-forest-star-72703-25637323/?
It's in their local rag too....
http://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/nufc...nited-in-bid-for-forest-star-72703-25637323/?
puds1970
Steve Chettle
I think Perch is an excellent proffessional.garrilla said:
IMO ability wise part of a reason we couldn't make that step upwards under previous managers though.
It's Baggio
John Robertson
RedMark said:
No he didn't. Billy made him captain for the back end of last season.
CC had Wilson as captain when Breckin didn't play.
Randy Bumgardener
AKA Randy Bumgardener
Codswallop ! Load of tripe if you ask me ! :dry:
It's Baggio
John Robertson
Swap him for Enrique.
Spring Heeled Jack
Spring Heeled Jack
Do you think we can accept the offer and send them Luke Chambers instead, and hope nobody notices?
truredwal
Official Photographer
Spring Heeled Jack said:
He's better at football than you are at jokes.
Spring Heeled Jack
Spring Heeled Jack
TruRedWal - Formerly known as the artist LeeWal said:
Yes you're right....Perch is.
Ravi
Upper Decker
f*** off Newcastle!
Just because you know we are going to steam past you doesnt mean you can take our most versatile player.
The only player I would let them have right now is Aaron Davies.
Just because you know we are going to steam past you doesnt mean you can take our most versatile player.
The only player I would let them have right now is Aaron Davies.
fsor12
First Team Squad
Clifford said:
Spot on mate ;D althought perch does have some good attributes he certainly nowhere near possess the abilty of Nicky Shorey or Gunter, when perch is on the pitch all he does apart from the odd tackle is give the ball away he doesn't have that killer pass like shorey and certainly not the quality.
cya Perch good bye to bad rubbish
andover red
Grenville Morris
I am in two minds about this.
On one hand Perch will never be a starter in our current squad and if he is starting for Newcastle then it would be an indication that their squad is not as strong as we are led to think. On the other hand he is a very versatile performer, provides valuable cover for a number of positions and would be our best pick at right back if anything happened to Gunter.
There is no indication of the size of bid so I wonder if this is designed as much to try and disrupt us as strengthen them. All in all I would say that a sizeable bid would tempt me to sell IF it enabled us to replace him with someone better.
On one hand Perch will never be a starter in our current squad and if he is starting for Newcastle then it would be an indication that their squad is not as strong as we are led to think. On the other hand he is a very versatile performer, provides valuable cover for a number of positions and would be our best pick at right back if anything happened to Gunter.
There is no indication of the size of bid so I wonder if this is designed as much to try and disrupt us as strengthen them. All in all I would say that a sizeable bid would tempt me to sell IF it enabled us to replace him with someone better.