McGoldrick

alabamared

Stuart Pearce
Depends how much Notts get for Kasper Schmeichel.
 

garrilla

Viv Anderson
Surely you don't expect Billy to sell him? Billy plays him almost every week, must see something we don't?
 

cole

First Team Squad
I have time for everyone in our time, but this bloke is seriously running on borrowed time now. I can'/t think of one useful touch or anything he did again today. Quite comical when we won a corner in the 2nd half and he was at the near post shouting to the crowd to make more noise. Shame he doesn't show the same determination and support that the fans give, he never broke sweat again out there. Surly the 3rd sub had to be Blackstock for this waster.
 

Hereford Red

A. Trialist
the most effort he made was giving a :w**ker: when we almost scored a second when he was on his arse facing the fans
 

sebs

Jack Burkitt
he played the through ball that led to that tyson opportunity just after nathan had got on. didn't really see much of him in the first half because the stands were absolute shit at bristol city, but for me he played a lot lot better once adebola was taken off. he held the ball up well up front, and you'll see on the highlights tonight or monday that he was involved in almost all our moves that led to chances which is what a striker should be doing.

i like him. i think he's young (22), got a lot to learn, but has all the physical attributes and just needs to get his head straight and if we're still in this league next season he'll get 10+ and make an awful lot of chances as well.
 

MaxiRobriguez

Bob McKinlay
He's a link up player who needs players constantly moving off him in forward directions so he can open up play.

Today we had;
Adebola doing a fine impression of a statue
Boyd who was 20 yards off the pace of our counter attacks
Cohen who was drifting inside and behind Goldie all the time

I'm no big fan of the lad, but if we had Ando, Majewski and Earnie playing today he'd have had opportunity to play a lot better.
 

goatboy

Grenville Morris
Surely you don't expect Billy to sell him? Billy plays him almost every week, must see something we don't?

A threadbare squad run ragged already?

Robbie's got a point though. Question is will we get the buggers to play off him next season or ship him out? I'd sooner have Taylor back up front for all the use McGoldrick is at the moment.
 

TRENTEND

Youth Team
I can understand him play adebola as it was against his ex club and sometimes they do come back and haunt you but as for mcgoldrick not for me when you have blackstock on the bench. He must be resting players knowing its the playoffs now.
 

RRRREDUN

Jack Burkitt
Couldn't get today. Sorry - I like the lad and can see loads of potential. IMHO, it's only when he plays that the Blackstock-on-his-own-up-front ploy works. He's got skills and I would be disappointed if he's forced out.
 

Kier

Banned
Cannot comment on today but McGoldrick has rarely impressed me, I don't see what benefit he brings to the team. His shooting is diabolical and weak, low work rate and too many times he is completely anonoymous. Complete waste of of ÂŁ1m.

Davies seems to rate him though so cannot see him being shipped out in the summer, if any striker will leave it will be Garner.
 

sammy the snake

John Robertson
Going nowhere, thankfully.

Seriously, he's only 22. He has real talent, watch this space, in the next couple of seasons he matures and will bag 20 a season at Champ level. Billy knows his stuff, 1 mill for a reason.

Boyd though, just WFT is he all about? the only similarity between him and Pele is that they both quite like a kick about every now and then.....
Boyd seems unable to read the game, and unaware of his job
Dave Pleat, seriously miss judged this one didn't he
 

Huxley.

A. Trialist
Going nowhere, thankfully.

Seriously, he's only 22. He has real talent, watch this space, in the next couple of seasons he matures and will bag 20 a season at Champ level. Billy knows his stuff, 1 mill for a reason.

Boyd though, just WFT is he all about? the only similarity between him and Pele is that they both quite like a kick about every now and then.....
Boyd seems unable to read the game, and unaware of his job
Dave Pleat, seriously miss judged this one didn't he

You aren't seriously suggesting Billy had no say in this are you?
 

InsideForest

Youth Team
No effort?? He closed down the ball very well today held it up and made some good passes. As he did when he came on against Newcastle.

Lost 7 away games in a row before this game, I think when we went on the unbeaten run McGoldrick and Adebola started most games. Not sure any of those two started the last 7? But people have their players they hate no matter what.
 

goatboy

Grenville Morris
Seriously, he's only 22.


I remember when 22 year olds were capable of playing like the grown men they are. I'll buy the "bless him he's only young" thing until they're about 20. When I was 22 I had to be as competent and dedicated in my job as the 30 year olds who'd been at it a decade, or I'd have been shipped out.
 

petenffc

A. Trialist
I just wanted to add a stat in here: 16 starts 13 sub appearances - 3 goals. Cost one million

My personal opinion is that he is a waste of space who puts no-effort in and he has the balance of Bambi on ice. I expected a lot from him at the start of the season with 17/18 goals last season but he has disappointed me. At least when Dele comes on he is a nuisance and get flick ons and creates space for other attackers.

As for Huxley " He has real talent, watch this space, in the next couple of seasons he matures and will bag 20 a season at Champ level."

I'm hoping that we will not be in the Championship in a couple of years time. I won't be disappointed though as Billy is doing a fantastic job.
 

petenffc

A. Trialist
I'm not sure but a lot less than Mcgoldrick yet he has the same amount of goals as him. 3 each. In fairness i have not seen much of Mcgoldrick (because i got a season ticket) but he has not impressed me when he has come on.
 

onlythetruth

First Team Squad
I know a couple of Southampton fans who thought they got the best end of the deal when we bought him from them

That tells you a lot - they have seen far more of him than we have

I am not holding my breath on him coming good to be honest
 
Top Bottom