Brendon Moloney sell or keep?
- Thread starter davejames
- Start date
Quinn^2
Viv Anderson
Keep
Depends on the fee really, promising player and has been doing a very good job for County this season. I'd like to see him kept for at least another season maybe loaned to a league 1 side to see if he can carry on the progression and force his way into our squad. But if we can get a good fee from them and that could go to improving the current first team squad then I can see him leaving. He's only proved himself for a 3rd of a season in league 2 after all and the gulf between that and the Championship is an absolute chasm. I'd like to see us hold out for 500k but think its more likely he'l go for 200-300k. He's not worth this just yet but think itl be a case of 'we know you have the money'.
S
Samuel
Guest
Keep. Will be able to give Gunter a good rest and be just as adequate.
lancecunno
First Team Squad
If it wasnt for Gunter, i'd love to keep him here. THe fact is, we have a better right back now, as good as Moloney might be.
I'll be sad to see him go, but i can't say we'll miss him too much. A shame really. A nice 500k (or maybe a Million if Clounty are involved) would be lovely.
I'll be sad to see him go, but i can't say we'll miss him too much. A shame really. A nice 500k (or maybe a Million if Clounty are involved) would be lovely.
red_outlaw
First Team Squad
We should keep him, without a shadow of a doubt. He really impressed me last season and is the only recent graduate of our academy who I believe has the ability to make it.
Of course, if County were prepared to pay in excess of £1,000,000 (let's face it, they can more than afford it), then I wouldn't stand in his way. I genuinely believe he's got the potential to justify that sort of price tag in the near future, especially as we're lacking in defensive cover. Let's also not forget the hidden covenant enshrined in January transfer window law (seen solely by Marthur) stating that it doesn't apply to Nottingham Forest for incoming transfers.
Of course, if County were prepared to pay in excess of £1,000,000 (let's face it, they can more than afford it), then I wouldn't stand in his way. I genuinely believe he's got the potential to justify that sort of price tag in the near future, especially as we're lacking in defensive cover. Let's also not forget the hidden covenant enshrined in January transfer window law (seen solely by Marthur) stating that it doesn't apply to Nottingham Forest for incoming transfers.
Marshall.
Jack Burkitt
I'd take £2M for him, then we can sign Bale.
Oakwood Red
First Team Squad
Doubt we will keep him as he had fallen out with Billy which was part of the reason for the on loan, shame.
NEWARKREDS!
Viv Anderson
keep or fleece the pie shaggers for £3m
Tommy1drop
First Team Squad
Keep him, one for the future and a good player at that, we should`nt sell our up and coming players just because someone comes sniffing, i think if they sold him they would regret it later!
Dadford
Banned
f*** him off, those in his fan club put the hoodoo on him in the same way they have done for Smith. Backing a winner 
C
clusternakker
Guest
"We are trying to sign Brendan Moloney but Forest want the best possible price for him."
aww diddums
aww diddums
alabamared
Stuart Pearce
Keep him. There is no real competition for places in defence; it's the only bit of the team that picks itself because of a shortyage of players.
Dadford
Banned
alabamared said:
Chambers at RB must be ahead of him, even Smith :nowink:
Nick.
Once known as Nick.Doyle.nffc on 'ere.
It would be sad to see him go, if Forest do agree to sell him to the Magpies.
Keep!
Keep!
dbarraclough
Viv Anderson
Keep
Billy is always going on about having a big squad. If he improves, he could be perfect back up for Gunter.
If we sold him then we would surely have to be in the market for a new RB cover anyway. Thats going to cost us another arm and a leg.
Billy is always going on about having a big squad. If he improves, he could be perfect back up for Gunter.
If we sold him then we would surely have to be in the market for a new RB cover anyway. Thats going to cost us another arm and a leg.
Darth Pierre
Banned
if gunter broke his leg, who else have we got?
sydney_red
A. Trialist
I watched him play for Notts against Port Vale...he's not ready for Championship football yet.
The Vicar
Geoff Thomas
I beg to differ Maloney is a far better BB than Chambers who by his own admission is not comfortable there. Of the 50 or so games I have seen him play in that position he made about 8 tackles and was run ragged numerous times. :mellow:Red Riding in the Hood said:
Eastwood Red
Grenville Morris
Keep him, but if we can get between £500k and £1 million let him go.
garibaldi79
A. Trialist
definitely keep him
Super-Garth
Viv Anderson
Sell, £500k to County.
They can afford him, we have Perch and other players who can play at RB if required, and if he's older than Gunter, surely we've got a better 'hot prospect' already in the squad
They can afford him, we have Perch and other players who can play at RB if required, and if he's older than Gunter, surely we've got a better 'hot prospect' already in the squad