Best Player

[Jonno]

Who would you say is our BEST player? On terms of value to the team, commitment, consistency and quality.

Not necessarily based on this seasons performances either.

Was having this conversation on the way back from Watford and the common answer was Cohen. How we miss him when he's not playing.

Cohen for me, close second is Earnshaw.

 

[It's Baggio]

Cohen for me, close second is Earnshaw.

Quite clearly.

 

[Jonathan]

Same again, for me!

I think that's glaringly obvious, though.

 

[dellaroc]

Earnshaw, followed by Cohen.

Honourable mention to Lewis, who will be a superstar.

 

[Jonno]

Same again, for me!

I think that's glaringly obvious, though.

I would have thought Cohen would be pretty high up but was curious to see who else pops up.

Expecting to see a lot of Earnshaw, Wes and Wilson votes.

 

[Gary]

Morgan and Earnie for me.

You forgot Gunter!

 

[It's Baggio]

Expecting to see a lot of Earnshaw, Wes and Wilson votes.

Not Wilson.

I rate him and I think there's a good Championship level centre back in him eventually but his form is far too up and down.

 

[Jonno]

Morgan and Earnie for me.

You forgot Gunter!

I also missed of Davies and a few others mate.

I think you see why....

 

[Caly in our Alley]

Only one vote for Smith so far. ???

 

[MaxiRobriguez]

I went for Earnshaw followed by McSheffrey.

 

[Brolin]

On top form, not a lot would seperate Earnshaw, McSheffrey and Cohen.

 

[Jonno]

Someone said to me that McSheffrey reminds him of Commons. In his playing style, not looks.

Anyone see it?

 

[Caly in our Alley]

Someone said to me that McSheffrey reminds him of Commons. In his playing style, not looks.

Anyone see it?

Slow, skillful but at times frustrating?

 

[Thompson]

i went for earnie and cohen not sure what order as i dont think it matters.

 

[mouldy]

Earnshaw without a doubt for me. Give him the ball in the area and most times you will be looking at a goal. Without him I don't know where we would be this season. Another though Cohen, high energy, talented and fully commited each and every game. I am very impressed.

 

[Tartan Tart Ups]

Cohen & Perch for me, they both have great engines, and could run all day. They can't be faulted for there commitment and consistency.

 

[Eastwood Red]

Where is the Lee Camp option?

 

[sedgred]

Cohen and Big Wes for me

 

[Loughborough_red]

Cohen without a doubt. Tuesday night was evidence enough for me that he is the one that makes us tick.

 

[Flaggers]

Cohen and Big Wes for me

Beat me to it.

 

[I Hate Derby]

clearly cohen and anderson both put the most effort in!

 

[Annesley Red]

Cohen by a mile

 

[Nffc Rich]

voted for Cohen and Anderson

 

[Deforest]

clearly cohen and anderson both put the most effort in!

haven't noticed that, i think cohen and perch put the most effort in. :wacko:

 

[clusternakker]

clearly cohen and anderson both put the most effort in!

Cohen, yes, Anderson, no.